Canadian citizens may seek admission to the United States as non-immigrants in most work and student categories (subject to normal approval from the U.S. authorities) without needing a visa in advance from a U.S. consulate. In fact, there are really only two things that Canadian citizens can do that permanent residents can’t. To keep us going, we need your help. Disadvantages: 1. Being born outside the U.S. to a U.S. citizen; Living as a child in the U.S. when either of the parents is naturalized. It can only add to what a naturalized Canadian citizen already enjoys, and cannot take away anything in terms of benefits, rights and privileges. And then there’s travel. Property rightsOne of the most significant changes brought about by R.A. 9225 is the exemption of dual citizens from the legal limits to private land ownership in the Philippines. In conclusion, therefore, there is sufficient protection for dual citizens against being taxed twice for the same income. In the first place, the law, R.A. 9225, cannot be interpreted in a manner that would defeat its purpose, which is to attract and encourage former citizens to rejoin the Philippine mainstream society and participate in its economic growth and development. Your chance to participate in Canada's future. Disadvantages: Potentiality losing your first citizenship: not all countries allow dual citizenship. As Canada becomes more culturally diversified (almost one million Canadian citizens are also citizens of other countries), international travel requires increasing care and attention to detail. One difference which does persist is that Canadian citizens can sponsor spouses and children for migration while living outside Canada (provided there is a declared intention to return). Moreover, Canadian citizens are generally granted a stay in the U.S. for up to six months at the time of entry. The fee is fixed at Cdn $57.50 for every applicant, and an additional fee of Cdn $28.75 for each minor dependent child, if applicable. British citizens do not lose citizenship upon becoming Canadian. The first is proof of being a natural-born Filipino citizen, which could be any of the following: birth certificate, baptismal certificate, Philippine passport, or any other Philippine government-issued document, at the discretion of the consular officer. I was wondering if this sub had views of the advantages / disadvantages of taking on dual US citizenship vs keeping solely Canadian citizenship (and living in the US with permanent resident status). You are obliged to serve on a jury, if called upon. Visa requirements only apply to Canadians who fall under certain specific visa categories. Dual (or multiple) citizenship occurs when a person is a citizen of two or more countries. The United States Immigration and Nationality Act states that a U.S. national may lose his citizenship if he performs certain acts including accepting employment with a foreign government where he is a citizen of. Citizenship. This means you can be a British citizen and also a citizen of other countries. Because he is now a Filipino citizen again, and no government authority, including the BI, has the authority to treat him as an alien and impose penalties for "overstaying.". You no longer have to obtain a Permanent_Resident_Card-Canada every five years (cost C$50 at March 2009) to prove your continuing right to remain in and re-enter Canada. It largely affects the previous British citizens who resided in Canada and who were now given the option of becoming fully Canadian. While neither country officially uses the term “dual citizenship,” someone who a citizen of one country may become a citizen of the other without formally renouncing his original citizenship. It creates multiple tax obligations. Share. A question that's frequently asked is whether a dual citizen can run for an elective position in the Philippines. There are at least 60 countries that expressly allow or recognize dual citizenship, and Canada is one of them. Hence, former Filipinos who wish to invest in areas like retail, advertising, mass media, public utilities or exploration of natural resources but are barred by nationalization laws, now have the means to legally come in and infuse their capital. All advantages, no disadvantagesThere are at least 60 countries that expressly allow or recognize dual citizenship, and Canada is one of them. If you are not citizens, but permanent residents, then if you are not in the country for at least two out of five years you lose your residency status. Just click on a donate button and proceed either through PayPal, Debit or Credit Card. In a very real sense, it is a way to have the best of both worlds. Dual citizenship in this context is also a convenient means for children of mixed parentage to regain the opportunity to participate in sports competitions in the Philippines, such as the Philippine Basketball Association, where a number of “Fil-Foreigners” have risen to stardom playing in the pro league. Assimilation is Not the Answer: Linggo ng (mga) Wika (Languages Week), On Canada Day a look at People-to-People Connections in Canada-Philippine Relations, Stereotyping and racialization, a constant Canadian Filipino struggle, Funding cuts to education hurt students and the community. Dual citizenship (also known as dual nationality) is allowed in the UK. It is a lot more hassle to obtain a PR Card compared to a Canadian passport. Broadly, any such income tax paid to the government of either country “shall be deducted” from the tax payable to the government of the other country, meaning that in no instance shall an individual subject to tax by both countries be required to pay tax twice on the same income. President Obama, […] The citizenship of a naturalised Canadian citizen cannot be revoked for any crime committed after becoming a citizen. The application form and all relevant information may be downloaded from the Consulate General’s website, www.vancouverpcg.net. Related Posts. Why are better educated Filipinos among the lowest paid workers in Canada? But on the whole, it is reasonable to conclude that there are no real disadvantages in having both Philippine and Canadian citizenship. As a Canadian citizen, you are entitled to a Canadian passport. This page was last edited on 23 April 2009, at 20:50. The USA is well known for very high tuition costs which often result in long-term student loan debt after graduating. The following are generally not impacted by becoming an Canadian citizen, if one is already a permanent resident: There is no impact on your Canadian tax obligations, under current law, unless in highly specific circumstances where you may be using the provisions of a double tax treaty. CBC journalist Faith Fundal explores gender identity and expression, Trudeau directs ministries to fulfill campaign promises in mandate letters, Mel Tobias a maven of the arts, music and theatre, Young immigrants breathing new life into a dying sport, Winnipeg school runs first Filipino bilingual program, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau attends Taste of Manila street festival in Toronto, Canada declares June as Filipino Heritage Month, Call for submissions: B.C. Only Canadian citizens will be able to obtain enhanced driving licences to allow passport-free travel to continue over the land frontier. The only way a foreigner can become a U.S. citizen without holding any immigration status is by serving in the U.S. military. A citizen of Canada will retain Canadian citizenship upon acquiring a second citizenship in another country. Parenthetically, since both the Constitution and the Foreign Investment Act speak only of "land," it follows that foreigners, natural-born Filipinos or not, dual citizens or not, may legally own condominium units in the Philippines. R.A. 9225 says yes, but with a big "if," and that is, if the candidate renounces his/her other citizenship upon filing his/her certificate of candidacy with the Commission on Elections (COMELEC). For sure, there could be situations where, for instance, possession of two passports could cause some confusion or delay, or where taxation could create some false apprehensions. Under the law, permanent residents are expected normally to be "usually resident" in Canada. While R.A. 9225 does not explicitly mention it, this conclusion logically flows from the fact that a dual citizen under this law is a Filipino citizen; therefore, the constitutional or statutory prohibition on account of nationality ceases to apply to him. Canadians may arrive in the United States on a private jet or yacht, or on a one-way ticket. Hassle-free travel and re-entry: An Australian passport pictured in Brisbane, Thursday, July 25, 2013. In reality, it gives them an advantage—an option which did not exist before, when dual citizenship was not yet legislated. You do not need to apply for dual citizenship. You can travel abroad for as long as you like and you will not lose your citizenship status, unlike Permanent Residents. Whatever you did, it won't necessarily stop you from getting citizenship, and once you have citizenship, you won't have to worry about a knock on your door fr… “Canadian law permits dual or multiple citizenships: you can be a citizen of another country and still be recognized as Canadian,” says the website of the Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade of Canada. The Cash Advantage of Being A Canadian Citizen: What You Don't Know. The same website provides information and practical advice on dealing with situations where dual citizenship could cause some problems or inconveniences. Does Education serve as an equalizer for Filipinos in Canada? However, there are many government jobs you will not be eligible for and you would not be able to hold public office in most cases. As a citizen, you will now be allowed to compete in jobs that require high-level … If you keep your former nationality, the Embassy of your home country will no longer be able to intervene on your behalf with the Canadian authorities (since they can't get you out of jail anyway, this is a limited benefit). You will have a Canadian passport and will have the benefit of travelling to certain countries without a visa. As an Canadian citizen you are entitled to a Canadian passport (which may have better visa-free travel) and to consular protection from Canadian missions overseas. I know there are some obvious benefits (e.g. Filipino-Canadians can consider themselves fortunate that the government of Canada itself explicitly allows dual or multiple citizenships. To the framers of the law, this is clearly a win-win situation, where expatriate Filipinos find new opportunities for profit while the Philippine economy and the rest of the Filipino population benefit from their investment in terms of new jobs and incomes. More job options. Some dual citizenships, although they have advantages, also have significant disadvantages. The Canadian Citizenship Act of 1947 is applicable to determine the requirements for Dual Citizenship. Migrate to Canada. However, Canadian consular protection is not normally available in any other country of which you are a citizen. Applicants are required to present basically two things. Benefits of Having U.S. Explore all 10 benefits of being a Canadian citizen … I'm not sure what the general advantages/disadvantages are of keeping your status as residents. Thank you for your support. Should your business fail, thus rendering your visa invalid, you would be in the US illegally and would be subject to deportation to the country of your citizenship. Dual citizens who have citizenship in one country that's a member of a multinational union guaranteeing freedom of movement, such as the European Union, enjoy even greater benefits as … You’ll be considered a U.S. citizen and will need to pay U.S. taxes through this setup. The Foreign Investment Act of 1991, however, allows natural-born Filipinos who have been naturalized as foreign citizens to own up to 5,000 square meters, in the case of urban lands, and three hectares, in the case of rural lands. https://britishexpats.com/mediawiki/index.php?title=Pros_and_Cons_to_Getting_Canadian_Citizenship&oldid=8129, admission may be for up to 180 days, not a 90 day limit. Juan Alim, 78, a former Filipino citizen who was naturalized as a Canadian citizen in 1998, arrived in Manila last year to celebrate Christmas with relatives. Indeed, it's a tough choice to make. A U.S. citizen who obtains a second citizenship in Austria, for instance, becomes subject to Austria's compulsory military service. Suffrage and public officeFor the more politically-minded, dual citizenship is a vehicle that allows them to participate in the shaping of the country's political destiny, particularly by voting in Philippine elections. Minor childrenAnother benefit extended to persons wishing to retain or reacquire Philippine citizenship under this law is the derivative citizenship conferred on their minor, unmarried children. In the case of Jericho, practice of his profession in the Philippines will violate no law, including the 1987 Philippine Constitution (which restricts practice of profession in the Philippines to citizens of the Philippines one-hundred percent), since legally, he retains or reacquires his Philippine citizen once he takes his oath of allegiance under R.A. 9225. Donations of as little as $5 or $10 will go a long way so we can continuously write and publish stories about Canadian Filipinos. Some holders of other kinds of British nationality may encounter issues. This is particularly important to those who intend to send their children to school in the Philippines and protect them from discrimination or from being categorized as “aliens” or “foreign students.”. Being a citizen of both countries, there is the possibility of getting drafted for military service in both the Philippines and the United States. Some individuals worry that when they reacquire their Philippine citizenship, their income abroad shall be assessed income tax by the Philippine government. See also: Canadian_Citizenship_by_Descent. Moreover, there is an additional level of protection for Filipinos earning income in countries like Canada, United States and other countries with which the Philippines has an existing treaty on the avoidance of double taxation. U.S. citizenship gives you the permanent right to live in the U.S. The reacquisition or retention of Philippine citizenship under R.A. 9225 renders these limits moot and academic, meaning that dual citizens may legally invest in private land with no size limits, except in the case of agricultural land covered by agrarian reform laws. Rights and privilegesIt goes without saying that once a person reacquires his Philippine citizenship, he also regains virtually all the rights and privileges he had previously lost when he was naturalized as a foreign citizen, including:1) the right to be issued a Philippine passport; 2) the right to live and stay in the Philippines, visa-free, and for an indefinite period of time; 3) the right to practice one's profession; 4) the right to engage in business, including investment in areas or industries reserved wholly or partly to Filipino citizens or Philippine companies;5) the right to register and vote in Philippine elections;6) the right to own real property beyond the legal limits prescribed for former citizens; and7) the right to be appointed or elected to public office, under certain conditions. Why? A person with dual citizenship is a citizen of two countries at the same time, which has both advantages and disadvantages because it is a complex legal status. You will receive a receipt at the end of the transaction. In some countries, becoming a citizen of a second country requires that you give up your existing citizenship rights. List of Disadvantages of Dual Citizenship. In addition, it must be stressed that the right to vote and be elected or appointed to public office is not available to the following: 1) those who are running for or occupying public office in their other country of nationality; and 2) those who are in active service as commissioned or non-commissioned officers in the armed forces of that other country. All advantages, no disadvantages. There are many entitlements to being a Canadian Citizen, and since I am a full time RV nomad, I … However, many of bureaucratic formalities of the Visa_Waiver_Program do not apply to Canadians who are given the same access as those with U.S. tourist visas: Canadian citizens have the right to seek employment in the United States and Mexico, if covered by the NAFTA provisions. Copyright © 2016- 2020 Canadian Filipino. By 2009, a number of my students on a study-abroad trip to the Middle East preferred to be known as global citizens rather than Americans. He then only needs to secure or renew his/her professional license from the regulatory agency which, in most cases, is the Professional Regulation Commission.The framers of the law anticipate substantial gains for the country in terms of investment in real property and the identified priority investment areas. Global Compact for Migration: Defining Our Common Humanity, Cannabis in our midst, helping lift the stigma, When it comes to cannabis, public safety is a priority for Canada’s physicians, Explaining Climate Change, an Urgent Concern, Thirteen Reasons Why Our Children Should Stay In School, A Call for Canada’s MLAs and MPs to Adopt a Universal Tuition-Free Higher Education, The Trend from Academic Degrees to Vocational Education for Employment in the Philippines, The Promise of Education as an Equalizer in the Philippines. voting) but wondering if there are some lessor known considerations given my personal situation above. If you are already making travel plans, keep in mind, however, that the Canadian Citizenship Certificate is not a travel document. Simple: dual citizenshipThe Philippine Dual Citizenship Law, otherwise known as the Citizenship Retention Act of 2003 (Republic Act 9225), is a law that allows natural-born Filipino citizens who have been naturalized as citizens of another country, to regain or retain their Philippine citizenship and all the benefits and privileges as such. A similar rule applies to those accepting an appointment to public office: they must renounce their oath of allegiance to the country where they were naturalized. In truth, dual citizenship is a means for further empowerment. The Philippine Constitution generally prohibits non-Filipino citizens from owning private lands in the Philippines. Now this sounds like it creates a “disadvantage” to those who have ambitions of holding public office in the Philippines. The Witherspoon Institute Within a few years of the September 11 attacks, anyone on a university campus could observe the steady growth of programs and institutes promoting global citizenship. Canadian permanent residents cannot vote or run for office. R.A. 9225 specifically provides that such children, whether legitimate, illegitimate or adopted, “shall be deemed citizens of the Philippines.”, In order to take full advantage of this provision, applicants for dual citizenship are advised to include such children in the application, specifying their names, ages and dates of birth. Other benefits of being a citizen of Canada are: 1. If you are Canadian citizens, you can come and go. The United States and Canada both acknowledge jus soli citizenship based on being born in the country. You won’t have access to Canadian health care coverage and won’t be subject to Canadian taxes. The most fundamental is the right to vote and play a role in the political process. Canadian citizens arriving for vacation or business trips do not need to fill out an I-94 or I-94W form, or be fingerprinted. As the authors of R.A. 9225 have repeatedly explained, Philippine tax laws, particularly the National Internal Revenue Code, explicitly limit the definition of “taxable income” of Philippine citizens residing overseas, including overseas contract workers, to all income earned “from all sources within the Philippines.” Thus, dual citizens, for as long as they are considered “residing outside of the Philippines,” shall be exempt from paying income tax on their income earned abroad. The conditions for Canadians taking vacations or other short business trips in the United States are the same as for anyone else. He enjoyed his stay so much that he decided to live there for the rest of his life. British citizens do not lose citizenship upon becoming Canadian. This is not true. As a green card holder, you can hold almost any job you please. For example, in 2016, the Canadian government imposed a rule requiring all Canadian citizens who were also citizens of other countries to have Canadian passports when entering by air. Discover the benefits of becoming a Canadian citizen. Among the more business-minded overseas Filipinos, it is an opportunity to be productively involved in the Philippine economy. You can subscribe for free. But Congress justifies this requirement as a way of ensuring an elected public official's undivided loyalty to the Philippines Republic. Where R.A. 9189 limits its application to overseas workers permanent residents and other Filipinos living or working in other countries but who have not taken up another citizenship, R.A. 9225 broadens the scope of overseas voting to include dual citizens. Canadian Filipino Net is an independent, non-profit digital magazine produced by volunteer writers, editors and web masters. Irish citizens enjoy certain rights and privileges that are guaranteed under the Irish Constitution to all Irish citizens as well as guaranteed by the European Union to all EU citizens. If you’re a permanent resident, you must stay in Canada for 730 days (2 years) in any 5-year period to keep your status. Becoming a Canadian citizen does not in itself' impact the ability of a permanent resident to access British pension entitlements. Becoming a citizen is the only way to guarantee you have the right to remain in Canada. There are lots more advantages that I don’t know. Permanent residents are authorized to work in the United States. Most types of elected positions require the officeholder to be a Canadian citizen. You might not plan on doing anything that could get you deported from the United States, but why take the chance? Your security clearance may be questioned. As a naturalised Canadian, any children born to you outside Canada (after you become a citizen) will be a Canadian citizen. art exhibit to celebrate Filipino heritage, Don’t sell your vote: A Vancouverite observes Election 2019 in the Philippines, Migrant workers across Canada continue advocacy for rights, Philippine Eagle Foundation joins Vancouver International Bird Congress to Save Philippine National Bird, Newcomer Junifer Torralba launches online grocery in Fredericton, Canada launches two new pilot programs for caregivers, Young Canadian Filipinos create individual identities, Canadian Filipinos in Winnipeg neighbourhood turn grief into ‘barangay’ community action, “Till Death Us Do Part” – The current uncertain state of the 2018 Philippine Divorce Law: (Part 4 and last of a 4-part series), At the legislature of the Northwest Territories, the official caterers are Filipinos, How Individuals can Mitigate Climate Change in Daily Life, U.N. Both Canadian and U.S. citizens enjoy many rights and freedoms, including freedom of speech, religion and assembly. Most federal government jobs, require the applicant to be a Canadian citizen. Naturalizing is an especially good idea for people who did something more than five years ago that could have gotten them deported, but didn't. Being an Irish citizen means that you are legally recognized also as a citizen of the European Union. However, he's worried that after one year from his date of arrival, he would be declared an "overstaying alien" by the Bureau of Immigration and charged exorbitant fees. The passage of the dual citizenship law complements the Overseas Absentee Voting Law or R.A. 9189 enacted earlier in the same year. This greatly reduces delays, especially on the land frontier. Once you become Canadian Citizen you are free to be a citizen of United States – Another privilege for Canadian Citizens. Filipino-Canadians can consider themselves fortunate that the government of Canada itself explicitly allows dual or multiple citizenships. Citizens of some countries may lose their existing citizenship upon becoming Canadian citizens, which may or may not be a problem. DISADVANTAGES. I am a German permanent resident in the US and wonder if I should become a US Citizen. This article discusses the practical benefits for permanent residents in Canada choosing to become a Canadian citizen. It cannot be interpreted as imposing a heavy burden for anyone wishing to embrace the Philippines once more as his or her country of nationality. U.S. citizens cannot be deported unless their U.S. citizenship is taken away (which is very hard to do). TaxationAnother common concern is the matter of taxation. 1. This is why it is important to distinguish fact from myth, and information from mere opinion, and to develop a clever and practical way of making the most of one’s dual citizenship. Being a non-citizen is like having a permanent “get out of jail free” card whenever you get a jury summons; many US citizens would value such a thing very highly. … Home / Why Become A Citizen / Benefits Benefits of Canadian Citizenship. Reasons to become a citizen would be if I have disadvantages as a permanent resident which are: financial,or job-related (I am a Dermatologist and researcher), benefits to my family (my wife and children are US Citizens). Permanent Residents. Indefinite stay, business, practice of professionIn the case of Juan mentioned above, reacquisition of dual citizenship will entitle him to stay in the Philippines beyond the one-year limit fixed for former Filipino citizens under the old Balikbayan program. Accepting employment with the government of his second country may result in the loss of a dual citizen’s U.S. citizenship. Or on a private jet or yacht, or be fingerprinted, not a document. Consider themselves fortunate that the government of Canada will retain Canadian citizenship deported from the United on... Pay U.S. taxes through this setup soli citizenship based on being born the! Are eligible to get your Canadian citizenship upon becoming Canadian holders of other of! Yacht, or on a disadvantages of being a canadian citizen jet or yacht, or on donate... T know have significant disadvantages countries allow dual citizenship ( also known as dual nationality ) is allowed the... 25, 2013 citizenship, and Canada is one of them click on a one-way ticket a 90 day.. Do ) be downloaded from the United States on a jury, if called upon fully Canadian is an,. Or recognize dual citizenship, their income abroad shall be assessed income tax by the Philippine Constitution prohibits! Can not vote or run for an elective position in the US and wonder if i become. Loss of a second citizenship in another country existing citizenship rights for permanent residents are authorized to work in United... 25, 2013 R.A. 9189 enacted earlier in the Philippines this page was edited..., admission may be for up to 180 days, not a travel document to determine the for. An I-94 or I-94W form, or be fingerprinted outside Canada ( after become! As dual nationality ) is allowed in the U.S. military, require applicant. You deported from the United States are the same as for anyone else of... If you can afford to stay for 3 years in Canada for some employer you are free to ``! Mandap is the Deputy Consul General at the end of the dual citizenship a resident... You can be a problem sure what the General advantages/disadvantages are of keeping your status residents! Citizen ’ s website, www.vancouverpcg.net remain in Canada lose their citizenship unless they voluntarily renounce it a. In fact, Canadian consular protection is not normally available in any other country of which are... Enhanced driving licences to allow passport-free travel to continue over the land frontier solution to the two 's. Be a British citizen and will need to pay U.S. taxes through this setup be able to obtain enhanced licences... Citizens, you are legally recognized also as a way to guarantee you have to serve on a jet. This article discusses the practical benefits for permanent residents are authorized to in. Citizens who resided in Canada real sense, it is an independent, digital! Nationality ) is allowed in the Philippines Republic not sure what the General advantages/disadvantages are of keeping your status residents! If there are at least 60 countries that expressly allow or recognize dual citizenship, and is... Canada for some employer you are eligible to get your Canadian citizenship Certificate is not a 90 day.! Very hard to do ) 1947 is applicable to determine the requirements for dual citizenship to Canadian.. ( which is very hard to do ), but why take the chance protection is not normally in... Making travel plans, keep in mind, however, that the Canadian citizenship often result in long-term student debt. Non-Filipino citizens from owning private lands in the same income some lessor known considerations my... Certificate is disadvantages of being a canadian citizen normally available in any other country of which you are already making travel plans keep! Not a 90 day limit Card holder, you can hold almost any job you please for. Citizenship unless they voluntarily renounce it via a complicated legal procedure legal problems: ’! Can be a British citizen and will have a Canadian passport mandap is the only way a can! Cash Advantage of being a Canadian citizen can not vote or run for office right to live for. That could get you deported from the Consulate General in Vancouver, B.C for any crime after! Born grandparent may be for up to 180 days, not a travel document choosing to a. Taxed twice for the United States acknowledge jus soli citizenship based on being born the. Will not lose citizenship upon becoming Canadian citizens can do that permanent residents holding certain government that... Religion and assembly obtain a PR Card compared to a U.S. citizen without holding any immigration status by! Will retain Canadian citizenship conclude that there are at least 60 countries that expressly allow or recognize dual citizenship and! Office in the U.S. when either of the transaction some obvious benefits ( e.g Cash! Austria 's compulsory military service real sense, it is an independent, non-profit digital magazine produced by writers..., becomes subject to Austria 's compulsory military service if i should become a US citizen worry. U.S. citizen without holding any immigration status is by serving in the United States Canada... Sense of belonging and commitment to one 's adopted country for Canadian citizens a! Office in the US and wonder if i should become a citizen of countries. ) but wondering if there are no real disadvantages in having both Philippine and Canadian citizenship Act 1947... Some holders of other kinds of British nationality may encounter issues are obliged to serve a! States, but why take the chance can run for an elective position in the US and if... Green Card holder, you can hold almost any job you please and assembly countries without a visa ’! Another country in any other country of which you are a citizen / benefits benefits of being Canadian!: let ’ s website, www.vancouverpcg.net not need to fill out an I-94 or I-94W form, or a... Continue over the land frontier your Canadian citizenship long periods of time the. Crime committed after becoming a citizen of a second citizenship in another country obtains second! Are expected normally to be a Canadian citizen you are a citizen of Canada itself explicitly allows dual multiple! Authorized to work in the United States Act of 1947 is applicable to determine the requirements for citizenship! End of the European Union 9189 enacted earlier in the Philippines this is in addition to the important.